A People's History of The Dismemberment Plan was a fan remix, the inclusions for which were hand-picked by the band themselves. Our remix was served up as the lead single, garnering rave reviews from various publications.

There are a few fantastic reimaginings here, though. Drop Dynasty’s ‘What Do You Want Me to Say?’ is squirmy, electro-damaged hip-hop that keeps the original’s verses intact but steers way left of the anthemic chorus, approximating the effect instead with a backward sample of Morrison and dropping in choice vocal bits for rhythmic effect.
— Pitchfork.com
Drop Dynasty’s flip-vocaled madness of ‘What Do You Want Me to Say?’ is impressive.
— Allmusic.com